Sunday, December 30, 2012

Short Film Reviews: My Summer of Love and Ladybird, Ladybird

My Summer of Love (4.5/5 stars) written & directed by Pawel Pawlikowski 

Set in the Yorkshire countryside, this film explores the friendship and romance between two girls. Mona (Natalie Press), the orphaned daughter of working class parents, lives with her brother Phil (Paddy Considine) above the family's pub. After finding salvation in prison, Phil has decided to convert the pub into a charismatic house of worship for other hungry souls. Tamsin (Emily Blunt) is the lonely, troubled daughter of a wealthy family. During the summer, the two girls form a fierce bond.

This coming of age film is very well done, with strong performances from the three leads, and more unpredictable that I'd expected. I enjoyed the two lead performances by Natalie Press and Emily Blunt. However the stand out performance, for me, was by Paddy Considine as Mona's Bible thumping brother Phil. Underneath the wafer-thin veneer of evangelical Christianity and goodwill, we continually sense his tightly coiled rage and frustration. We aren't surprised when Mona's overt anger and scorn of her brother's newly adopted faith -- along with Tamsin's casual, unpredictable cruelty, -- triggers Phil's repressed anger.

I highly recommend this to people who enjoy cinematic realism and edgy coming of age stories.

Ladybird, Ladybird (4/5 stars) written by Rona Munro & directed by Ken Loach

I am a fan of Ken Loach's brand of social realism, based on the handful of his films I've seen so far (including Sweet Sixteen and Kez). This is in spite of the fact that, having worked in human services for many years, you'd think I'd seen enough painful social realism to last a lifetime without needing movies like this. :-)

I deeply appreciate Loach's ability to turn a compassionate eye on members of society many people dismiss. In this case it's a troubled British welfare mom who eventually bears nine children, despite losing six kids, one by one, to the foster care system. (Yup. This kind of thing happens a lot. Trust me on this.)

When the film opens, Maggie (Crissy Rock) is devastated after her four children -- all fathered by different dads -- are removed from her care for negligence and endangerment. It's an all-too-familiar story. Having had violence imprinted on her at a tender age by her abusive father, she has been drawn to a series of destructive relationships. The latest is Simon (Ray Winstone). This, along with her poor judgment, leads to her losing her kids. She finally has a chance for a loving, non-violent relationship with her new lover, Paraguayan humanitarian Jorge (Vladimir Vega) and they hope to start a family together. But "the system," for understandable reasons, doubts her ability to change and is unlikely to give her a chance.

To its credit, the film doesn't take the easy route by portraying Maggie as a victim. We watch her repeatedly make appallingly poor choices, including her refusal to cooperate with social workers and police. If you'd been in the room with my daughter and me while we were watching this movie, you would've heard me yelling at the screen a lot. ("Stop shooting yourself in the foot, Lady!" and "For the love of God, USE A CONDOM this time" were common refrains.) Nevertheless it was impossible not to have empathy for her, and I wanted things to turn out well for Maggie and Jorge.

As much as I judged her actions, I couldn't condemn or dismiss Maggie. First, it was made clear that at the root of her hostility to social services was deep rage because, as an abused child, she had not been protected. Secondly it was impossible to forget just how screwed you can be when, at a tender age, home is an unsafe place and basic human trust is unable to germinate. There but for the grace of God ...

In my opinion, this film wasn't as good as Kez and Sweet Sixteen, but it was an outstanding movie. Solid writing, strong performances, and nuanced character development work together to create a film with complexity worthy of the difficult subject it tackles.


  1. I never heard of second one, but My Summer of Love is really great, glad you liked it. It's such a great story and my favorite performance from Emily Blunt.

    1. I'm glad you liked My Summer of Love as much as I did. :-)

  2. I'm not a big fan of My Summer of Love, but the performances were terrific. Ken Loach is a blind spot for me. I really need to dig into some of his work this year.

    1. Just curious, why didn't you like My Summer of Love? I know what you mean about not liking a movie but appreciating the performances. That happens with me too. :-)

      If you decide to watch some Ken Loach films, I'll be curious to hear what you think. My daughter got me hooked on this director with Sweet Sixteen then Kez. I thought they were both great, especially Sweet Sixteen, though it's a dark movie.

    2. I'm not sure how to describe it. I felt the storyline with Phil could've been handled better. It wasn't exactly melodramatic, but it just seemed off to me. Can't really explain it. :)

      Actually, those are the two Loach films I want to start with. Not sure if I'd post something on them, but I'll let you know what I think when I get to them.

    3. I think I understand what you mean. :-) I'm glad you're going to check out those Ken Loach movies. I look forward to hearing what you think


Hello, and thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts -- reader comments make this blogging gig worthwhile. :-) Due to excessive spam, we are now moderating all comments. Like that dude in the Monty Python skit, we just Don't ... Like ... Spam. I will try to post and respond to your comments as quickly as possibly.